Differentiation

How Starbucks and Dunkin differentiate themselves in the same industry

https://awario.com/blog/starbucks-vs-dunkin-donuts-analysis/

Starbucks Vs. Dunkin

            Starbucks and Dunkin are two of the largest coffee shops in the United States, and both utilize social media platforms for marketing purposes. Today we will look at how the two both compare each other regarding their social media efforts.

Similarities

            Both Starbucks and Dunkin have a heavy presence on social media platforms such as Instagram, X, and TikTok. Both have embraced highlighting seasonal specials such as pumpkin flavored drinks in the fall or holiday inspired beverages in December and encourage engagement and content sharing between the audience sharing photos and experiences. The two brands have also embraced apps which inform users of new products and inform audiences of limited time menu specials, online ordering, and maps showing the nearest store for pickup.

Source

Differences

            Although Starbucks and Dunkin maintain tens of millions of followers on their various platforms, their overall strategy differs in several ways. Starbucks is focused on storytelling and user engagement. Starbucks doesn’t just post pictures of coffee; they tell a story. Visual storytelling is about more than aesthetics — it’s about conveying a message that resonates with their audience (Medium, 2024). Starbucks also has a much larger international footprint on social media with 73.8% or 1.2 million users and maintains much larger levels of user engagement on their various platforms. On the other hand, Dunkins’ focus is more localized, and its audience tends to be from the United States and represents 26.3% of users or 424,000. In addition to this, Dunkin has implemented a simple strategy to enhance its social media presence, namely, marketing a colorful and quirky personality online (Medium, 2022).

While Starbucks focuses mainly on storytelling and content and embraces an upscale and calm image, Dunkin has embraced a personality which posts frequently while focusing on pop culture and trends and has also teamed up with celebrities for advertisements and partnered with companies to create new products. For example, in 2019, Dunkin partnered with the candle maker Homesick to create a “Dunkin inspired” candle. This was so successful that Dunkin’ launched a second collaboration with the trendy natural candle brand this fall (Business Insider, 2020).

Source

Conclusion

I view Starbucks and Dunkin social media marketing strategies as symbolically siblings where one is an introvert and the other is an extrovert. Both will appeal to a segment of audiences who prefer the type of environment and message they convey. Dunkin is more of the loud, impulsive sibling, while Starbucks is quieter and more reserved. There is no intrinsically better strategy here, but the way the two companies wish to present themselves to audiences in different ways while still embracing many of the same ideas. Both Dunkin and Starbucks are attempting to sell similar products. What they prove through their various social media platforms is that it is not what they sell that they are focused on through these channels, but how they make their audience feel through these platforms and the interactions and engagement which follows. These two brands show that despite being from the same industry, they can utilize social media with vastly different psychological approaches.  

References

Your Media Strategy (2024, May 30) The Secret Behind Starbucks’ Social Media Strategy. Medium. https://yoursocialstrategy.medium.com/the-secret-behind-starbucks-social-media-powerhouse-69de0d5b6c46

Ahuja, Mallika (2022, March 06) Dunkin’ Runs on Social Media. Medium. https://medium.com/marketing-in-the-age-of-digital/dunkin-runs-on-social-media-bf4e69a9ce43

Taylor, Kate (2020, December 29) How Dunkin’ stole Starbucks’ crown as king of social media in 2020 using TikTok stars, purple drinks, and coffee-scented candles. Business Insider. https://www.businessinsider.com/how-dunkin-became-the-viral-star-of-2020-beating-starbucks-2020-12



Leave a Reply